Problems With The GNOME Shell
Phoronix: Problems With The GNOME Shell
Debates surrounding Linux desktop environments, especially the new Ubuntu Unity shell and the GNOME 3.0 Shell, tend to be very polarized. There also tends to be lots of trolling by users when such debates occur within our forums and elsewhere. But what do graphics driver developers -- and those not out simply to rant -- think of the new desktops? Well, Alex Deucher of AMD recently switched over to the GNOME Shell and he's provided a list of issues he's had with the experience thus far...
After reading that blog post, all I could think was "try E17".
desktop PC users are a dying breed. Everyone tends to optimize for mobile platforms, yet, gnome3/unity have large issues with small screens - fixed-height windows that don't show the buttons etc. I also moved from Gnome3 to KDE because of these issues. At least, KDE is not trying to be "netbook UI".
Not sure I'd agree with desktop users being a dying breed. I think it's more that people are using multiple devices now, and they're trying to make a "one size fits all" interface, which often will fall down in a heap.
Originally Posted by dekomote
But you are truly to use the same interface to all devices? The design principles that apply and go well for a tablet UI doesn't fit to a desktop UI neither a pda/smart phone. So, at the end, you have a product that doesn't fit any segment.
Gnome-shell is for dumbasses. We call them normal users in other circles. I am wondering why developpers would ever want to use Gnome, ever.
Now basically Gnome-shell != Classic Gnome, wich is what he's complaining about. Other problems are a product of first version releases; kind of stripped down in terms of functionality.
Want more terminals? Hello there tty's. You better be having propper mode setting in there.
All other problems should be handled by applications. Gnome-shell is after all a semantic Unix desktop: one tool per task.
Other than that Gnome-shell could be win for tablets.
What do you mean by that? They created "Plasma-Netbook" for this use case (and I'm using it right now).
Originally Posted by dekomote
It's definitely not for newbies. I don't know for who the gs is.
Originally Posted by V!NCENT
My problem is simpler than that, it just won't work.
On my Laptop, it won't work with the ATI Radeon drivers, and using the FOSS drivers, unfortunately, cuts my (already short) battery life in half - making my laptop unusable.
On my Desktop PC, Gnome-shell crashes every time I launch it, it simply can't handle my triple monitor setup.
I've currently switched to KDE, which I am actually really happy with. The latest version works well and does exactly what I want.
I put my minimize buttons back almost immediately
gnome-tweak-tool lets you choose which buttons you want your windows to have.
I don't know who could possibly have thought that removing the "minimize" button was a good idea, but s/he obviously has a completely different idea about how I should be using my PC than I do.
Having said that, I don't miss the maximize button in the slightest.
Moving the mouse cursor into the top-left corner of the screen shows you all your windows again. And it's actually easier to un-minimise the correct window again when they are all displayed like this.