OK, let's not talk about me...
ANYONE that wants to play ETQW native and use the build-in VOIP, PulseAudio is total c**p for the simple reason that as soon as you press ANY of the VOIP keys, game crashes.
Taking in account that ETQW is, IMHO, the best *native* FPS for Linux (and even after Valve games are ported, it will continue to be the BEST FPS, IMHO, YMMV) , that's real bad.
There many people reporting problems with other native games with PA so, it's not only a problem of WINE...is a wide spread problem but with PA.
As for two sound cards under ALSA i used to have it but wasn't easy and , IIRC, not working at same time, Eventually i removed one because i really didn't need two cards, my GC uses HDMI exclusive to exit video (but because TFT monitor uses still a VGA, it has a converting plug, sound is not by it , monitor doesn't have speakers witch i consider a good thing because give me total freedom to use whatever i want as speakers goes...i like my games audio loud to piss of neighbours
Ooooppssss....i talked about me
… and you call others trolls…
Originally Posted by Teho
Anyway thanks for the information that Michael wouldn’t give, mattst88!
When the audio starts stuttering after a Wine update, I think it is more than fair to blame Wine. And I am playing plenty of native games - including ET:QW - without issues.
But I am sorry that I opened up this can of worms if we are just to get another PA rant thread. Especially when it was over one rather innocuous vent.
Just re-refresh(installed) steam with 1.5.10 now all the text is blank 8( I can't play RO2..
Right, The game crashing is /totally/ PA's fault. Just like all problems in Blender are caused by firefox and all problems in Gimp are caused by irssi. Maybe we should blame the programs that are unstable for their crashes rather than blaming random 3rd party stuff.
Originally Posted by AJSB
Ah, thanks for answering this question (not that i asked it), but i jumped into this thread, very specifically, to find this answer. So thanks
Originally Posted by mattst88
You may actually want to look into this a bit further, Wine developers have commented on PA on many occasions - and the way they see it, certainly does not gel with what you are saying. This may not be the case anymore, but with PA it used to be a case of PA not keeping up (requiring more latency vs. ALSA/OSS/CoreAudio), i am not sure how well PA2.0 works (i don't have it installed) but have heard the situation has improved (although from some comments in this thread, maybe not enough). So i don't care to get into some debate over PA + wine, especially when the article/thread isn't really about it.
Originally Posted by Hamish Wilson
I have noticed that there exists a branch of wine, that is more geared for multimedia and obviously supports pulse - and tries to improve audio in wine via some patches, PA and other improvements/fixes;
Archlinux package: https://aur.archlinux.org/packages.php?ID=52143
Wine-Multimedia git: http://repo.or.cz/w/wine/multimedia.git
I don't really know much about it, because for my own Wine usage i am using wine-rt - which is wine patched for RT / Jack audio connection kit usage. I am mainly running VSTs via FSThost with only the odd other (wine) audio app / utility, which wouldn't require using ALSA (directly) or PA, anyway. (Jackdbus is my soundserver (using ALSA backend).
anyway, i just thought i would post the wine-multimedia branch for those who might be interested.
Last edited by ninez; 08-01-2012 at 12:12 AM.
I second this
I'm with bachinchi; the entire purpose of the article was to announce WINE defaulting to "off-screen rendering", yet never bothered to explain what that was or what it could mean for users. As such, it was completely useless for most readers.
Off the main topic here (WINE).
Originally Posted by Teho
I normally stay out of the PA debates as it usually "just works" for me... Just yesterday on Arch I was trying to play a video w/audio through HDMI from an NVIDIA card (using proprietary drivers) using VLC and had extremely distorted sound. Switching from PA to ALSA and selecting the proper output (annoying as 4 HDMI audio devices were listed with same name) actually resolved the sound issue. Would you blame VLC for that too?
Considering it is an actively developed project and it is very much an outlier compared to everything else I am running, yes I would blame the program. It is up to the project to support modern Linux infrastructure - and for the moment that is PulseAudio.
That being said, in the case of Wine, I do not even know if it is PA related at all. All I know is since my last update Wine's sound has been stuttering. Considering that whenever there has been a Wine problem in the past it was because of a regression or an unintended bug in Wine itself, I do not think it is that much of a stretch to assume the problem is with Wine.
Yes, and very much so! VLC doesn't work with PulseAudio even more than Wine does. You could "fix" the sound problem by reverting to the old interrupt method in PulseAudio, but it's obviously VLC's fault for not supporting the new timer method. A whole lot better fix is to drop VLC and install KMPlayer or such. I have, and I am a lot happier now.
Originally Posted by Kamikaze