Problems with X 7.1?

[Rob Williams]

Are there known video problems with X 7.1 that I am unaware of? I did a few Google searches, and of course people have had issues, but it didn't seem to be worse than previous versions.

With 7.1, I installed the latest NVIDIA driver and had this happen:



The above picture is Kate, but I have also had similar problems with Gentoo. When I installed 7.1 on my laptop and Intel desktop, and recompiled the video drivers, the system would crash. Let me tell you, it can be a PITA to revert to a previous X version :-P

Anyways, I am wondering if there have been fixes to this that I am unaware of? I tried older video drivers, but the problem was worse with each try.

[James]

I thought the nvidia drivers didn't support >=xorg-7.1

[Michael]

NVIDIA drivers currently do not support X.Org 7.1.

Rob, this might be of assistance. Basically there are some work-arounds for masking X7,1, but it isn't the best solution, and GLX_EXT_texture_from_pixmap isn't supported with either binary driver.

[Rob Williams]

Ahh thanks for the link. So in reality, it just doesn't make sense to move beyond 7.0 or whatever else you have. It seems to have more downsides than upsides, unless you don't want to use 3D maybe?

[Michael]

Originally Posted by Rob Williams

Ahh thanks for the link. So in reality, it just doesn't make sense to move beyond 7.0 or whatever else you have. It seems to have more downsides than upsides, unless you don't want to use 3D maybe?

NVIDIA's 1.0-9XXX driver binaries, which support X 7.1, shouldn't be out for at least another month or so... A bit slow to the game, and X 7.2 should be out later this year.

[mrapples]

If you do something along these lines in Gentoo again, be sure to quickpkg xorg-x11. This will make reverting much less of a hassle. Also, portage should not allow you to install 7.1 alongside the nvidia drivers in the first place, as xorg-server conflicts with them.

[James]

Reverting is a big pain. I ran into this exact problem and couldn't get myself reverted back to 7.0 easily. I didn't know about quickpkg at the time, so your results may be much better (let's hope).

As a result of my frustrations, I'm now running K|Ubuntu on my primary machine.

[Rob Williams]

I should have used quickpkg... good point. TBH, Portage probably did not let me install it, I don't remember. I likely uninstalled 7.0 or 6.8 first then forced an install of 7.1.

Originally Posted by James

Reverting is a big pain.

Well, the easiest way I have found was to simply:

emerge -C libX11 x11 xorg-x11
ACCEPT_KEYWORDS="~x86" emerge -e =xorg-x11-7.0-r1 x11

[mrapples]

A good method of handling this in gentoo was posted on the forums, it can also be used to revert back by unmerging xorg-x11 between steps 2 and 3

Originally Posted by lftsy of the gentoo forums

1) I made a save pkg of xorg-server-1.1.0

quickpkg xorg-server

2) I set xorg-server-1.1.0 & x11-base/xorg-x11-7.1 masked

echo =x11-base/xorg-server-1.1.0 >> /etc/portage/package.mask
echo =x11-base/xorg-x11-7.1 >> /etc/portage/package.mask

3) I used this script to update my computer

while true ; do emerge -uD world | grep dependency | sed "s/^.*\(\".*\"\).*$/echo =\1 >> \/etc\/portage\/package.mask/" | sh ; done

you can observe with a

tail -f /etc/portage/package.mask

packages that will ba masked
kill (Ctrl+C) when no more package will be added

[Rob Williams]

I like my way better, hehe. It's worked on two PC's. Though, that way is probably more failsafe.